Comedies rarely receive the respect they deserve, which is a shame.
Critical accolades are generally reserved for verbose, showy dramas about
"important" subjects, with comedies dismissed as too frivolous to be
considered as art. Hopefully that will change with the delightful
screwball film "In And Out". Not only is "In And Out" the funniest film
of the year, it's also one of the best. Writer Paul Rudnick ("Jeffrey",
"The Addams Family") has concocted a gay fairy tale that manages to
deliver admirable messages about community, family values and the
importance of being yourself, while maintaining a light, giddy tone and
delivering big laughs.
Three days before his wedding, Indiana teacher Howard Brackett (Kevin
Kline) gets the shock of his life when a former student (Matt Dillon)
outs him during an Academy Award acceptance speech. Brackett frantically
denies being gay as tabloid reporters turn the small town into a media
circus. There's a lot more to the story, but revealing the surprises
would spoil some of the fun.
From its opening moments, Rudnick and director Frank Oz establish "In And
Out" as a broad farce, and they never let up the pace. Kevin Kline, who
won an Oscar for "A Fish Called Wanda", leads the exceptional cast with
another outstanding performance. In one extremely funny scene, Kline's
Howard Brackett receives a long, unexpected smooch from an unlikely
source. During the kiss, Kline uses body language brilliantly to convey a
wide range of emotional reactions without ever saying a word. This guy
can do more acting with one leg than most performers can do with their
whole bodies.
Kline is surrounded by one of the stronger casts in recent memory. Joan
Cusack is a riot as Brackett's co-dependent fiancée. Virtually swallowed
by a billowy wedding gown, she takes the ditzy character's insecurities
and escalating sense of desperation and plays them to great comic effect.
As a smarmy tabloid reporter, Tom Selleck gives an assured, almost impish
performance, one of the finest of his career. Debbie Reynolds, fresh from
"Mother", is focused and funny as Brackett's mom, a determined woman who
tells her son, in no uncertain terms, "This wedding MUST happen. I need
beauty, flowers and nice placemats. It's like heroin". Wilford Brimley
and Bob Newhart give sturdy supporting performances, and Matt Dillon has
a great time as Cameron Drake, a vacuous pretty boy film star who seems
like a cross between Brad Pitt and Luke Perry.
Complaints about "In And Out" are bound to surface. Some fundamentalist
Christians will condemn the film as an elaborate piece of gay-positive
propaganda, while certain uptight gays and lesbians will claim the film
plays off homosexual stereotypes. What's interesting is that both
statements are essentially true. "In And Out" uses humor, heartland
imagery, and a musical score straight out of "Hoosiers" to create a
sympathetic atmosphere for its gay-positive message. The film is an
extremely effective piece of propaganda and that's a good thing. The
"subversive" message of "In And Out" is that being gay is no big thing,
that real communities will accept and embrace their gay brothers and
sisters and eventually wonder why there was ever a fuss in the first
place. Rudnick's agenda is to send audiences out of the theater with
smiles on their faces and minds a little more open. We can certainly use
more propaganda like that.
As far as playing off gay stereotypes, "In And Out" does it often and
well. A number of jokes work off the common perception of gay men as
somewhat prissy neat freaks who dress impeccably and love Streisand,
musicals and poetry. But the film doesn't stop there. In the world of "In
And Out", everyone is a stereotype. Reporters are opportunistic jackals,
small-town folks are sweet, wide-eyed yokels, fashion models are bulimic
bimbos, and actors are self-absorbed boobs. Characters are painted with
broad strokes in farces, that's simply the nature of the beast. Hopefully,
those on the far left and right will settle down and enjoy the film's
great humor and enormous good will.
Along with its wonderful performances and pacing, "In And Out" boasts an
razor-sharp script, bursting with as many pop culture references as a
dozen episodes of "The Simpsons". In fact, "In And Out" plays a bit like
a big-screen sitcom. That's just another part of Rudnick and company's
canny approach. Using familiar images and a screwball comedy format, they
have created the first wholesome, all-American, family values film about
gays. "In And Out" is one comedy that truly deserves respect.
Copyright © 1997 Edward Johnson-Ott