|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Secondhand Lions
|
  out of 4
 Review by Harvey Karten 3 stars out of 4
|
Put a 12-year-old kid in a rickety wooden farm removed from
civilized life with no phones and no TV's and you have a
parent's dream and a youngster's cabin fever. Or would you?
In Tim McCanlies "Secondhand Lions," which deals with one
real queen of the beasts and two metaphoric ones, a
pre-pubescent boy whose irresponsible mother dumps him on
the porch of two aging uncles whom he has never met, learns
that even without kids his own age or marvels of the
technological world, you can be quite happy, even actualized.
"Secondhand Lions," which is rated PG, is a welcome break
from movies that are so obviously slanted toward its targeted
audience (like "Finding Nemo" and "Good Dog!"). This one
spins a tale that's blessed with superb acting while painlessly
teaching the young fry in the audience that senior citizens can
be fun--though perhaps only if they'd had experience in the
French Foreign Legion and are capable of warding off the
aggressions of both hormone-crazy teens and saber-rattling
swashbucklers.
We're introduced to Mae (Kyra Sedgwick), a floozy who
apparently runs through a bevy of boyfriends in the 1950's only
because she has no money to survive on her own. Recalling
that her young boy, Walter (Haley Joel Osment), has two
bachelor uncles said to be sitting on millions, she hustles the
sullen kid off to the Texas ranch hoping that he can learn the
location of the loot. Though Walter is shocked that Garth
(Michael Caine) and Hub (Robert Duvall) have neither phone
nor TV, he settles into what could be the dullest summer of his
young life.
Writer-director Tim McCanlies takes us back into our own
childhoods which, if we were lucky included Sunday night
storytelling sessions by the fire in summer camp, the
counselors fascinating us with tales of the Indians and
motivating us to plunge into yet another week of so-called tribe
war. Walter has no problem accepting the eccentricities of his
uncles, having been told what to expect, resulting in his
nonchalance at their literally shooting fish out of the water and
even buying a "used" old lioness which they had intended to
release from his wooden crate and then shoot- as red-blooded
Texans really do during hunting season on some of the ranches
catering to the rich. Whether he believes their stories of foreign
intrigue is irrelevant: after all, as Uncle Garth tells him in a
eulogy to fiction-writing, truth is irrelevant as long as you
believe.
In one sense, "Secondhand Lions" is the other side of the
"Mame" coin. In Jerome Lawrence and Robert E. Lee's play,
Mame Dennis is an elegant Beekman Place sophisticate who
drinks endless cocktails and lives life as one huge happy party.
Young Patrick, who lives with her for a while, feasts on caviar
and learns to mix an expert martini. In another sense, Uncles
Garth and Hub had allegedly led exotic lives in Morocco, in
which Hub rescues a princess from a sheik's harem and Garth
saves the newly captured Hub. Is the story believable? We get
a strong clue at the conclusion of the film. As for the credibility
of the performers, Haley Joel Osment, who is beginning to
shows signs of puberty, is ideally cast as a 12-year-old at the
age that is still entranced by tales of adventure whether true or
not, just before he enters high school and turns into the age of
one who is bored by everything. Michael Caine seems more
Mayfair than Middle America giving Robert Duvall the most
believable casting as a codger, who having really lived is not
afraid of death and does not consider big-city living and
Ecstasy-driven rave parties the apotheosis of a rich life.
"Secondhand Love" has some sentiment toward its
conclusion, but what's wrong with schmaltz? This is one of
those features that can be embraced by people of all
ages except for high-school kids, who are bored with
everything.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|