| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|  |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
When Michael and Mark Polish wrote the script for
"Northfork," they may have had no idea that their reach for
timeless, universal human values could be taken right out of this
week's headlines. As warring powers in the Middle East give
the Bush administration's road map for peace a try, the Israeli
government is faced with the prospect of having to move Jewish
settlers in the West Bank and Gaza out of homes they've
occupied perhaps for decades. Given the religious fervor that
ties many of these people to the land "given to them" by biblical
injunction, they will inevitably be torn not only from their four
walls but from their very identity as Orthodox Jews.
While religious zealotry does not impact on the people being
displaced from their homes in Michael Polish's "Northfork," they
nonetheless accept that inevitably from a group of black-suited,
fedora-covered bureaucrats who look like refugees from "The
Matrix," or they put up a fight to the death in their determination
to remain on their Montana land, the only homes they know.
Like faceless bureaucrats everywhere, the funereal officials
offer some money to compensate the displaced from their
rickety lodgings and feel good about what they are doing
because their government plans to flood the land, dam the
water, and create power for the greater Montana community.
"Northfolk," however, is only partly a cautionary note against
progress, seen as leaps forward which are not achieved without
considerable human cost. In its grand theme about the nature
of identity, the Polish brothers tackle not only the loss that
comes to people when they are expelled from the land that they
love but even more important, our need to be a member of a
family that loves us, that does not abandon us either physically
or psychologically. In realizing that motif, the Polish brothers
focus on eight-year-old Irwin (Duel Farnes), an orphan who is
dying and whose parents among those forced to move out of
the village of Northfork, Montana return him to the man who
had taken care of him, Father Harlan (Nick Nolte) rather than
become inconvenienced by the need to look after the child. A
fevered Irwin, convinced that he is an angel who will be rescued
by others of his ilk, conjures up a cast of characters who are so
strange that people in the audience who believe in the literal
images of the afterlife will be more afraid of death than ever.
How long can we really put up with people like the androgynous
Flower Hercules (Daryl Hannah), who tells the boy that she is
both his father and his mother; Cup of Tea (Robin Sachs), who
serves the hot drink between his dry, cynical statements; and
the legally blind Happy (Anthony Edwards), whose limited sight
is bolstered by a pair of glasses with six or seven lenses and
considers himself a scientist in addition to being an angel
without wings.
"Northfork" moves along its glacial pace in a non-linear
fashion, telling two stories: one, which deals with the loss of the
old vision of a landholding, agricultural America founded in 1776
which gives way to the faceless, post-1955 industrial giant,
features James Woods in the role of Walter O'Brien who with
his son Willis (writer Mark Polish) are one pair that make up The
Evacuation Committee. Like modern-day salesmen eager to
make their quota to enjoy company-paid trips to Hawaii, each
pair needs to get sixty-five residents to sign waivers and
abandon their homes and in return the company men will get
title to a small plot of land. The other story finds the unfortunate
orphan substituting his dreams for his bleak reality, though he is
fortunate in having the local religious leader care for him while
the search goes on.
Heavy as this all sounds, "Northfork" is not without humor,
albeit of the driest kind, some so corny as to be camp. When
one pair from the Evacuation Committee barges in on a
lovemaking couple, they warn, "Stop screwing around." Seeing
a ragged mat in front of one door, a bureaucrat explains,
"They've worn out their welcome." The magic realism includes
a church which is not much more than a roof with pews, the
congregation looking not at stained-glass windows but at the
more appealing sight of the broad Montana landscape in the
raw.
True to their nature, the Polish brothers give their film the
Indie look with a capital "I," desaturating the colors into ten
shades of gray while lighting the angelic characters strongly to
take the place of the more literal wings and haloes. Like "Twin
Falls Idaho" and "Jackpot," both Polish films done in a matter of
days rather than months or years, "Northfork" was knocked out
on location in Montana in just twenty-four. Original that this film
may be, it does recall the angels looking down and commenting
on Berlin in Wim Wenders's "Der Himmel uber Berlin" ("Wings
of Desire") and is of a piece with the same deadpan humor and
desire for family connection in their "Twin Falls, Idaho."
As the old advisory goes, this is not for every taste. If you thrill
to "Terminator 3" and area agog at "The Hulk," you'd probably
pass this one buy. If you're looking for the antidote to the usual
summer fare, this is your pic.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|