|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
The expression still holds: Build a better mousetrap and the
world will beat a pathway to your door. It doesn't really matter
for what building your metaphorical mousetrap is constructed.
What's important is that the product be admired for its
originality. Sales will confirm success.
Nigel Cole puts together an unusual mousetrap in Tim Firth
and Juliette Towhidi's "Calendar Girls," an idea that in retrospect
seems such an obvious marketing ploy that if you're a woman in
her fifties, you'll slap your head and say, "Why didn't I think of
that?" Too late now: if you use felines instead of mousetraps ,
the cat is out of the bag. A group of women from the sticks of
England though pleasant sticks at that with rolling hills and
typically adorable shops in a North Yorkshire town get an idea
whose genius is overtaken only by what we urban folks would
erroneously say is its banality. Members of a Women's Institute
in this North Yorkshire town who gather regularly to hear and be
bored by guest speakers' presenting topics as The History of
Broccoli when they're not getting advice on how to bake better
and darn socks with more pizzazz or competing in bake-offs,
devise a scheme to raise money. The money is not needed for
selfish purposes. When the husband (John Alderton) of Annie
Clarke (Julie Walters) dies in short order of leukemia, the
women want to present the hospital with some furniture in his
memory. Annie and her best friend Chris Harper (Helen Mirren)
devise an unusual plan, inspired by Chris's leafing through her
son's girlie magazine. Why not raise money by printing a nude
calendar, but instead of the typical playmates, the fifty-
something women would themselves become January through
December?
After quite a bit of playing with this idea, one which would
seem as radical in a small, southern American town as it did at
first among the women in the Women's Institute chapter, the
dozen women under Chris's leadership decide to pose nude,
albeit with private parts covered by cakes or palettes or what-
have-you. They hope that the calendar sales in the region
would raise money to provide some memorial items for the
hospital. They must overcome their own modesty, e.g. allowing
the photographer at first to set up the camera and then leave
the room, and they must get beyond the hostility of some of the
men, particularly Chris's son, who is being razzed by the girls in
school, and Chris's husband, Rod (Ciaran Hinds), who
considers the plan immodest and foolish.
"Calendar Girls" is hit and miss at first, as the women titter and
blush and pop their eyes at the thought of taking it all off, a
reaction that would seem not disingenuous but naive to anyone
to the left of the Taliban. But as the story develops and director
Cole penetrates the surface kidding around and girlie games,
we find considerable friction, not only between one of the
husbands and his wife but between the two best friends
themselves. Ultimately, the calendar idea takes off far beyond
the wildest dream of any of the participants, and the women,
giggly as pre-adolescents in a sex hygiene class, get their
fifteen minutes of fame and then some.
The film, of course, reminds us of Peter Cattaneo's "The Full
Monty," which in 1997 hit the bull's eye dealing with unemployed
Sheffield steel-mill workers who like the women in Cole's
picture need money and most of all need something of broader
significance to do than storing jam for the winter. Cole extracts
fine ensemble acting, the interplay between Mirren and Walters
centering the story. You don't need to be a middle-age
Yorkshire resident to appreciate this: Simply approach this
story's humor on its own level, a tale freer of cynicism than just
about anything turned out by Hollywood.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|