| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |   |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|   |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
1½ stars out of 4
In a more idealistic clime than we in America face today, I had
my heart set on joining the Peace Corps going into parts of the
world that did not have the advantages that we take for granted
in the U.S.A., teaching English as a foreign language (in my
case), while serving realpolitik interests of our country by
making people in the Third World love us. While a career in the
New York City school system put me back into reality, and
rationalizing that I'm helping less fortunate people in the Big
Apple, Peace Corps dreams dissipated. Now, only a handful of
volunteers to that noble organization, which drew a lot of good
press during JFK's administration but is scarcely mentioned
today, have been harmed. Volunteers from the West who go to
poor nations, Fourth World, if you will, to administer medical aid
and distribute food are in a far more precarious situation that
Peace Corpsman. Often, residents of these areas are not only
starving and dying of diarrhea, typhus and pneumonia but find
themselves in lands overrun by opposing armies in civil warfare.
The places administered to by the principals in the film helmed
by Martin Campbell ("Vertical Limit," "GoldenEye") are plagued
with a plethora of handicaps. When they're in Ethiopia, they're
short of supplies because some Western countries (read: the
U.S.) refuse to administer succor at the time that the East
African nation is under Communist rule. They're in Cambodia at
a time that Khmer Rouge guerrilla fighters are liquidating the
intellectuals of their own country (for more on this, rent Roland
Joffe's "The Killing Fields," about a N.Y. Times reporter who
remained in Cambodia after American evaluation) while fighting
off an invasion of Vietnamese Communists. Their stay in
Chechnya puts them in at least equal danger, given the uprising
of militants seeking independence from the Russian
government. Director Campbell takes us to places that mirror
the conditions during the time span of the film, 1984-1995: to
Montreal standing in for London; to Eastern Canada for
Chechnya; to rural Thailand and Bangkok substituting for
Cambodia, and to the desert sands of Namibia to represent
Ethiopia.
"Beyond Borders" attempts to enlighten and entertain us in
least two ways. One is as travelogue, avoiding the sterile
movies taken by tourist boards by introducing explosions,
machine guns, a hand grenade and an exploding land mine; the
other is as romance, one between two relief workers, Dr. Nick
Callahan (Clive Owen) and Sarah Jordan (Angelina Jolie).
Quite a bit of good came out of the project, specifically in getting
Ms. Jolie to take an interest in the world outside Hollywood
where she became a Goodwill Ambassador for the UNHCR
(United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) two years
ago, visited a camp in Namibia set up for refugees from Angola,
and posted journals on the website of UNHCR at www.unhcr.ch.
The other bit of good is that the film production company left
behind valuable stuff for the communities they
photographed office furniture, generators, tents and the like.
The film falls short however, in both areas: for entertainment
we see Ms. Jolie looking, mugging for the camera, and
performing as though she were a blow-dried TV newscaster.
Wherever she goes, not a hair on her head falls out of place nor
does she get any dirt on her mostly white clothing. Her romance
with the strikingly handsome and manly Dr. Callahan (whom
you'll recognize from his role as the title figure in "The
Croupier"), comes out of the blue without appropriate exposition.
Callahan simply grabs Sarah and kisses her, they fall into bed,
and from then on we hear Callhan express such endearments
as how he can never get his mind off her though he adds that
he thinks she should go home to her wan husband, Henry
Bauford (Linus Roache) and her two children all of whom are
neglected by this feminine prisoner of naive idealism.
Moreover by spreading the relief work over three distinct
areas one parched by the sun, the other a victim of wind and
show, while the third is inhabited by stereotypical Asian people
moving their cattle along the road and riding bikes writer
Caspian Tredwell-Owen is so all-over-the-place that we are just
getting into the spirit of one area when the project presumably
ends and our principals are elsewhere.
Doctors Without Borders, which appears to be the kind of
relief organization illustrated herein, simply does not exist as a
James Bond one-crisis-after-another phenomenon. Do doctors
such as Callahan regularly bribe the various armies to get their
medicine through to the people, and are their lives in constant
danger whether in Cambodia, Ethiopia or Chechnya? For those
in the audience who are not that familiar with the crises, do we
get enough information on the roots of the chaos? Not when
we're in all these areas, including London (Montreal standing
in), are sandwiched into a couple of hours making for a
superficial treatment indeed; one which is wholly without humor
or chemistry between Callahan and Sarah or a credible
explanation of Sarah's deserting her husband and her kids,
except for one thing: Is it really better to go to these charity balls
where a rock singer yells "Should I Stay or Should I Go" with
considerably less variation than the Schumann work played by
Sarah in her luxurious London digs, and the typical life of the
rich involves spending hours in art galleries listening to stuffy
lectures on meaningless abstract paintings?
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|