| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|    |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
"Life's a bitch and then you die." This aphorism is never
spoken in Mike Leigh's latest look into working class trials, nor,
ultimately, does Leigh draw that conclusion. But his leading
character, the wonderful Timothy Spall, does say at one point,
"We are born alone. We die alone." Not original, but then, the
down-home people like taxi drivers, supermarket checkers, and
custodians of nursing homes are not about to quote
Kierkegaard.
But philosophies they do have, nonetheless. Following a
departure with his biopic about Gilbert and Sullivan three years
ago, Mike Leigh returns to his signature observations of reality
in "All Or Nothing," which, if Charles Dickens did not have a
copyright of the title could have been called "Bleak House." And
life is bleak bleak bleak in the three families observed by Mr.
Leigh, its writer-director, whose "Secrets & Lies" might have
been filled with more intrigue and powerful emotions while this
time around Leigh is consumed with pathos. Leigh takes us to a
working class development in Southeast London to look at three
families and the problems brought on not only by the lack of
money but by the frustrations engendered by the boredom of
unskilled work and the obstinacy of their teen-aged children.
With an ensemble led by Timothy Spall as Phil and Lesley
Manville's as Phil's common-law wife, Leigh centers his
attention on Phil, giving us a strong feeling for what a day's work
is like for a taxi driver with his diverse assemblage of
passengers. He injects humor into one conversation between
the laconic man behind the wheel and one English-speaking
French woman who wonders aloud whether his kids are a fat as
he is and who chastises him for taking her through a tunnel
without warning her in advance of the route. As if the grind of
his job were not enough, at home he suffers the indignities of
hearing his obese son Rory (James Corden) regularly tell his
parents to bugger off, nor can he feel much pride in his equally
obese daughter Rachel (Alison Garland), who is a cleaner in a
home for the aged and is conversationally virtually catatonic.
While we watch the shenanigans of his neighbors, as
well who include the always drunk Carol (Marion Bailey) and
her daughter Samantha (Sally Hawkins) who comes on to boys
as a tease; and the relatively happy supermarket checker
Maureen (Ruth Sheen), who daughter Donna (Helen Coker) is
knocked up and beaten by her jerk boy friend Jason (Daniel
Mays)-Leigh's main concern is the loss of love between Phil and
Penny and the way that a family crisis offers hope of
redemption.
Those who know Timothy Spall's work those lucky enough to
have seen him in other Mike Leigh films such as "Life is Sweet,"
"Secrets and Lies" and "Topsy Turvey" realize that a film like
"All Or Nothing" is worth seeing even if just for the chance of
watching his expressive, unshaven face register terminal
resignation. When he turns off both his cell phone and the line
leading to the office of the taxi manager, we expect him to
depart his vale of tears and perhaps, were it not for an accident
that offers the hope of renewed love at least for a while between
him and his family, that would be his expected fate. The
principal drawback to the movie is the lack of subtitles, and
while this is not a Ken Loach job which would be impossible to
comprehend without that assist, the low volume of speech
throughout the story requires a keen and attentive audience ear.
"All Or Nothing" seems about as valid a picture of the
desperation of a working-class family, particularly one whose
daily grind has erased most traces of love, as you can get.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|