Review by Harvey Karten
No Rating Supplied
If "Pauline & Paulette" were an American film rather than a
Belgian one using the Flemish language, its title might have
been "I am Pauline." That level and level-headed country's
entry into dramatizations of the mentally handicapped features
two of Belgium's most celebrates performers, and what's more
this is one of those rare pictures that deal with the lives of older
people. (That means over 60, Americans, not 35.)
Filmmaker Lieven Debrauwer, who was born in the small
Belgian town of Roeselare , seems to want his audience to
realize that we can learn more from the lives of what we'd call
developmentally disabled people than they can from us. While
the film does not prove this, we see by the final scenes that the
"normal" sister, the one who is taking care of the retarded
individual, realizes what she is missing once she turns the
former over to an institution.
The siblings are the handicapped Pauline (Dora van der
Groen) and her gifted, ambitious sister Paulette (Ann Petersen).
Paulette runs a dressmaking shop in a provincial town, takes
pride in treating each customer like a valued friend, and ties a
mean gift wrap around each item of clothing that she sells. She
also takes part in the village operetta group as she has been
doing for the past thirty years and is pretty much unconcerned
about Pauline, who visits the shop regularly, is fond of Paulette,
and doesn't make too much of a negative impact on the
customers. When Pauline's caretaker and sister Martha
(Julienne De Bruyn) dies suddenly, Paulette and her younger
sister Cecile (Rosemarie Bergmans) learn from the will that they
can divide the inheritance as long as at least one of the
survivors takes care of Pauline.
While we're shown a fairly predictable conflict between Cecile
and Paulette, both of whom are interested in the money
provided by the will but neither wanting to take Martha's place
as caretaker, our attention is focused principally on Pauline.
While Pauline cannot speak a complete sentence, tie her
shoelaces or cut her food, she can water flowers in Paulette's
garden and go on errands to butcher shop armed with a list of
meats to buy from the meanspirited shopkeeper (Camilia
Blereau). There is isn't a heck of a lot of action in this small
movie which could easily fit on a 26-inch TV, but the modest
enterprise has hearts, flowers, and lot of music from " Waltz of
the Flowers" of Tchaikovsky's "The Nutcracker." We can see
that while Pauline has barely the understanding of a normal five
year old she has no concept of death, emphasizing that Martha
broke a cup when she fell down dead ("she's sleeping on the
floor") she is friendly, smiles easily, and kind of grows on the
people she's around. Some of the people, yes, but not Albert
(Idwig Stephane), who is the live-in boyfriend of Cecile and
being an intellectual has no tolerarance for the disabled, elderly
woman who has come to live temporarily with them.
This is a real movie about real people taking care of each
other, resenting each other's presence at times, and living their
lives as best they can with whatever gifts they have been
afforded. We in the audience do care about Pauline as long as
she doesn't spend too much more time with us than the 78
minutes she has been given by Debrauwer.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|