Loners like Seymour Parrish are fascinating because they lead such insular
lives. They are not necessarily rejects of society nor are they deviants in the
strictest sense. They want to belong but simply do not know how, thus alienating
themselves from everyone in the process. In "One Hour Photo," Seymour Parrish is
one loner who wants to belong to a family, and starts to develops an attachment
to one.
Seymour ("Sy") Parrish (Robin Williams) works at a one hour photoshop in a
department store not unlike Walmart, here called SavMart. He is a fine employee
and always looks to give the customers the finest prints he can make, despite
problems with maintenance who know next to nothing of the finer details of photo
processing. Sy is committed to his job and knows his customers well. There is
one customer he is fond of, perhaps a little too fond of. The customer is Nina
(Connie Nielsen), who always wears black leather and lives with her aloof
husband, Will (Michael Vartan), an architect, and their young son, Jake (Dylan
Smith), who plays violent video games. Nina's existence is one of comfort
despite having a husband who is never there for her or her son. Sy knows nothing
of their marital problems - he just knows the pictures he has printed of them
for years. They seem like a happy family and Sy wants to be one of them, often
imagining himself as Uncle Sy. He has also made extra prints of their pictures
and, in one truly eerie scene, he has collectively pasted all their prints on
one wall space in his living room.
Sy does not live a charming existence. He works in a photo shop that seems
sterile and bland at best. His home is grayish and completely devoid of color.
He watches "The Simpsons" on television and never flashes a smile. This man has
no pleasures in his life. But by getting close to Nina at his workplace, he
looks for details. She reads the spiritual lessons of Deepak Chopra and finds
himself reading it as well. In one scene that sums up the character's insularity
crossed with populated public places, Sy seats himself at a fast-food restaurant
in a mall where Nina happens to be. Needless to say, Nina is surprised at Sy's
interest in Deepak Chopra. We may also be surprised that perhaps Sy never goes
to eateries at the mall because there are so many people - he seems more
comfortable alone or talking to Nina.
Sy even tries to buy Nina's son a warrior action figure but he refuses to accept
it. Will considers the "photo guy" a "stranger" and is alarmed by his
appearance. But eventually Sy discovers a secret involving Will that he uses to
his advantage. Of course, this also opens the doors to Sy's lack of reality
about families in general. Sy is now at a boiling point and we are not sure what
he will do his next. Even his firm boss (Gary Cole) is driving him crazy.
"One Hour Photo" is directed by music-video director Mark Romaneck, but don't
let his background turn you off. He does not bombard the screen with flash cuts
and fancy editing tricks but rather cools off the dramatics in favor of a
Kubrickian mode - sets, lighting and color play more substantial roles than
camera moves. The gray colors inside the photo mart, the malls, and Sy's
apartment make us feel queasy. This is not just Sy's insular existence but his
own state-of-mind, and some of it may remind us that malls are not exactly
bursting with color and imagination - they look just as dull and placid as Sy's
apartment. Mostly "One Hour Photo" is not in-your-face. Like Robin Williams's
performance, it is subdued and this factors in how creepy the film is. At times,
it is nearly unwatchable. Anytime Sy talks with Nina or her family, we feel we
are on edge, unsure of what he may say or do.
Robin Williams, fresh from a quietly menacing turn in "Insomnia," makes Sy
compassionate and harmless yet still threatening. His own search for a perfect
family and the flaws he finds shows how unrealistic his expectations are. He
reminds me of Jerry, the psychopathic, smiling stepdad in "The Stepfather," who
also craved the perfect family and basically went berzerk when they did not
fulfill his promise. Sy is not as prone to such murderous tendencies as Jerry
was, but his insularity and his needs prove to be as explosive and surprising.
It is one of Williams' most powerful roles in a long time, far more reserved
than usual. If Williams did this to wipe out the thick sentiment of "What Dreams
May Come" and other post-"Patch Adams" oddities, he has succeeded admirably.
"One Hour Photo" never veers into familiar thriller cliches, nor does Sy Parrish
prove to be some one-dimensional monster in need of psychiatric help. I could
have lived without the flashback structure, however, and would have liked more
emphasis on Nina - the fact that she calls her husband neglectful is only
skimming the surface of her troubled family. Taking visual cues from "The King
of Comedy" and "The Conversation," Romaneck still finds a way to make"One Hour
Photo" grate our nerves. We want Sy to belong to a family, and we would like to
him to be happy. Sy wants all the familial trappings that life has to offer - in
short, the American Dream. He just has a creepy way of showing it.
Copyright © 2002 Jerry Saravia