| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 | --- |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|   |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
No Rating Supplied
If you called a teenager's baggy pants "the cat's meow" he'd
think you were awfully uncool, and yet, ironically, the term "cool"
is itself a direct descendant of the feline expression that was all
the rage during the roaring twenties. And how appropriate that
Peter Bogdanovich's new film is so called because "The Cat's
Meow" is not only a riveting recreation of one of America's most
exciting decades seen in the microcosm of William Randolph
Hearst's huge yacht but is a terrific showcase for some actors
who are not all that well known to Americans and yet are
exquisite in their roles. Most notable of all is the twenty-year-old
Kirsten Dunst, up from comic roles in teen movies such as
"Dick," "Drop Dead Gorgeous," and "Bring It On" now performing
as Marion Davies--who at the age of twenty-seven actually took
part in the festivities on the Hearst yacht in November of 1924.
Dunst is so drop dead gorgeous in this absorbing picture that
she could wipe out the whole popularity of toga parties among
college guys today who would cheerfully replace them with '20's
themes. If the real Ms. Davies looked anything like Ms. Dunst,
one could see how Orson Wells got the inspiration for "Citizen
Kane," still considered by connoisseurs to be the greatest
American film of all time, in part about the romantic affair
between Davies and Mr. Hearst.
Peter Bogdanovich is in his element a man noted for directing
period dramas like his notable "The Last Picture Show" in 1971
(about how characters' lives intertwine in a Texas town during
the 1950s), and the less-than-successful "Daisy Miller" three
years later (brought down by Cybill Shepherd's mediocre
performance and an altogether cold ambience),
The story is based on an actual event that took place on
William Randolph Hearst's yacht in November 1924, an endless
party featuring guests who are prominent in various fields and
who join the newspaper magnate for a cruise around the
California coast (with outdoor scenes actually filmed off the
southern Peloponnesian town of Kiparissia). Hearst, one of the
richest men in the world at the time, was prominent not only in
the newspaper business and the instigator (through the news
media reports of brutalities) of the Spanish-American War, but
had formed Cosmopolitan Pictures for the sole purpose of
producing films starring the love of his life, Marion
Davies whom he had met in 1917 and with whom he
maintained a long, sincere relationship marred by Hearst's
wife's refusal to grant the man a divorce.
Played stunningly by Edward Hermann who looks quite a bit
like Hearst at the age of sixty-one the large, powerful man
keeps an eye on his passengers, principally Ms. Davies (Kirsten
Dunst), but also on famed producer Thomas Ince (Cary Elwes),
who had made his reputation producing expensive Westerns
but whose prominence had sunk of late; Louella Parsons
(Jennifer Tilly), who was to become the most celebrated gossip
columnist of her day; Charlie Chaplin (Eddie Izzard), madly in
love with Marion Davies, who is attracted in turn but refuses to
chuck her relationship with Hearst; and British novelist Elinor
Glyn (Joanna Lumley), the Maggie Smith of the movie who
feeds us acerbic one-liners.
Through the interaction of the personalities on deck, we
become aware of Mr. Bogdanovich's theme: Hollywood (like the
corporate world in general) is corrupt. Sincere friendships are
rare. Individuals are out to milk one another for what they get,
offering something in return that they hope will satisfy those who
can favor them with privilege, power and money. Ince, for
example, is down on his luck and wants Hearst to merge his
studio with Ince's and promises, in return, to keep on eye on
Davies who appears to be tight with Chaplin. Davies, of
course, wants to continue leading the rich life and particularly to
keep the parts coming to her from Hearst's studio though her
affection for the large man is sincere. Parsons, who acts the
bimbo for most of the tour around the California coast, wants to
leave her job with a paper in New York to cover the Hollywood
scene for a Hearst paper on the West Coast.
As the group of favored persons dance frenetically to
Charlestons, party and orgy the night away with the help of
bootleg booze and marijuana, a shot rings out. A guest is shot
in the head and Hearst's entire career is about to go down the
tubes. Unless...unless...
As stated, the story is based on truth. A murder actually did
take place in that very vessel, one which was superficially
examined by the San Diego authorities but which the Los
Angeles police department refused to investigate further.
Hearst is off the hook, but a viewer of this astonishing
picture which, like Steven Peros's play on which it is based has
to wonder how the estates of some of these Hollywood
personalities will take it. Did Louella Parsons really become
famous because she manipulated Hearst into granting her a
lifetime job in L.A.? Is William Randolph Hearst actually a
murderer? Did Thomas Ince, who produced the masterpiece
"Civilization" a pacifist allegory in support of President Wilson's
international policy sink so low that he sought Hearst's backing
only to offer his services as a private eye in return?
Whatever the fallout after the movie's April 2002 U.S.
opening, the story's significance as an exposition of some
fascinating cinema history may slip your mind, but you're likely
not to forget Kirsten Dunst's intense, convincing, gorgeous
performance. Meow.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|