Men may have only one thing on their minds, as my dates
back in college used to tell me, but "Thirteen Conversations
About One Thing" is not about that. The story is about
something even more important: happiness. The
conversations, which are introduced by director and co-writer Jill
Sprecher in a non-linear fashion mixing up past, present and
future are vignettes, a series of skits, some comical, some
poignant, and unlike other films that employ that method of
communication the characters do not all meet by the conclusion.
Like the more commercial enterprise, Paramount Pictures'
"Changing Lanes" (which is not only about the literal wrong turn
taken by a car on New York's FDR Drive but about the ways
that the principal characters change their lives), "Thirteen
Conversations" is a movie about ideas. Sprecher's work is
theatrical, not only because most of the scenes take place
within closed spaces, but because the story is dialogue-driven
as are many productions on the legitimate stage. But since the
tale does not really require what's usually called a cinematic
treatment, everything works just fine thanks to some superb
acting particularly by Alan Arkin and some sharp, credible
dialogue throughout by Karen and Jill Sprecher.
The movie deals with particular people found in four distinct
occupations: attorneys, academics, housekeepers and
insurance claims adjustors all of whom talk mostly to others in
their own fields but whose lives intertwine with those in other
professions when the exposition so requires. Gene (Alan Arkin)
is the manager of a department in a New York insurance firm
who, like all the other personalities in the story has personal
problems that affect their work. Gene is divorced with a
rebellious, drug-addicted son, Ronnie (Alex Burns), whom he
must regularl bail out of jail. His conversations, like those of the
others, are not directly about The Meaning of Happiness and
How To Find It but all of Sprecher's people deal tangentially with
that issue at all times. Gene, for example, regularly asks co-
worker Dick Lacey (Frankie Faison) why Wade Bowman
(William Wise) is always smiling, even though Wade is not as
intelligent as he is. Gene's envy of Wade's perpetually good-
natured bearing affects the relationship of the two men unfairly.
Troy (Matthew McConaughey) is a good-time guy, a moralistic
assistant D.A. who believes strongly in the law as the governing
force in society, but the guilt he feels when he is responsible for
a hit-and-run disaster strongly affects his bearing. Walker (John
Turturro) is a physics teacher who has lost the thrill he used to
get from classroom activities, is married to Patricia (Amy Irving)
and has a woman on the side on Thursdays (Barbara Sukowa),
while Beatrice (Clea DuVall), a housekeeper, discusses with
her friend Dorrie (Tia Texada) the way a particular accident has
changed her life.
The production notes cite Bertrand Russell's book "The
Conquest of Happiness," which deals with the three obstacles to
that condition, namely envy, boredom and guilt, and my oh my,
how Ms. Sprecher, previously known for the 1997 film
"Clockwatchers" (about four bored temps who form a friendship
that hurts their careers), manages to infuse Russell's concept
subtly into this film. The inhabitants that populate "Thirteen
Conversations" alternate between a giddy optimism and a foggy
pessimism, some managing to find a modicum of happiness
while others become more turned off on life as they see little
other than guilt, envy and boredom ahead.
Alan Arkin cements the story, just as he did most other films
that featured his ability to act like Everyman ("The Heart Is a
Lonely Hunter," "The Russians are Coming..."). He brings a
hangdog expression and a commentary with considerable
humor to every conversation he's in, such as in his meeting with
Troy, the lawyer, in which he expounds on a fellow worker who
won a $2 million lottery and had not had a moment's peace
since. In a variation of the old expression, "Be careful what you
wish for: you may get it," the insurance adjustor warns that "May
you get what you want" is actually a gypsy curse, and Sprecher
knows how to manipulate her characters on the big screen to
prove how some, especially Troy, are ruined by that very idea.
Sprecher directs with Pinteresque pauses that seem to ask us
in the audience to fill in the blanks with our own takes on the
dilemmas faced by these ordinary people. Let's hope that the
years ahead bring us more films about ideas, stories that are as
good as this one, because what the world has hungered for
since Aristotle is to encounter tales that cause us to reach into
our souls to understand what we may expect from life.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten