Like several of Eddie Murphy's past films (1998's "Holy Man"), "Life" is
a perfect example of a film with an identity crisis. Let Murphy loose
and he can be a dynamite comic (1996's "The Nutty Professor"), but too
often he is mired in an uncomfortable mixture of comedy and drama. If
Murphy wants to be treated seriously, why not make a straightforward
dramatic piece, instead of intermingling it with juvenile comedy, and
vice versa?
Spanning 60-odd years and beginning in the Prohibition era of 1932,
Murphy stars as smooth con man Ray Gibson who, along with straight-laced
banker Claude Banks (Martin Lawrence), finds himself owing a large debt
to a bootlegger (Rick James). Paired together to travel from their home
of Manhattan to the deep south of Mississippi on a bootlegging journey,
they unwittingly witness the death of a black man caused by racism, and
then are accused of the murder, sentenced to the Mississippi State
Penitentiary for life. As the decades fly by and they remain locked up,
Claude and Ray's friendship survives many different hurdles as they
begin to suspect that they are going to die without ever being free
again.
Does this sound like a rousing yuk-fest? I think not, and although
"Life" does boast a few humorous moments (I liked, for example, an early
scene where they enter into a "No Coloreds" restaurant and the waitress
tells them that they only have "whites-only pie"), the overall story is
more depressing than anything else, since we know what we are basically
watching is two innocent mens' lives being wasted away. In something
like 1994's "The Shawshank Redemption," this idea worked because the
subject matter was treated with a realism and intelligence. In "Life,"
it is mostly an excuse to give us one-liners heavily laced with the
F-word (and worse).
"Life" also has severe pacing problems, as it often has a tendency to be
marginally entertaining one minute, and then brain-numbingly dull and
misguided the next. This major problem probably owes itself to the fact
that there is no story arc to the film, nor is there much of a "story"
to begin with. Sure, we follow Claude and Ray through an epic 60 years,
but not much really happens in those years, and, at one point, a whole
28 years passes by within a two-minute montage! The only good thing
about that is I knew the sooner Murphy and Lawrence began to get their
faces more heavily applied with "old man" make up, the sooner it would
be over.
Eddie Murphy and Martin Lawrence are strong presences throughout, and
have at least fairly substantial material to work with. Murphy,
especially, rolls things off his tongue at such a rapid rate that it is
usually very humorous, and apparent that fellow comic actor Chris Tucker
is only imitating him. Lawrence, meanwhile, portrays the more touching
of the two characters as he is most affected by the prison experience
and sees many of his future plans ultimately shot down, including his
love relationship with a fetching young woman (Lisa Nicole Carson). Come
to think of it, maybe the movie should have simply been retitled "Eddie
and Martin," as written right above the "Life" title on the poster. The
movie focuses so much on the two that the rest of the many characters
are either sorely underused or come off as mere afterthoughts.
Aside from the two central actors, also making an impression is the
music score by Wyclef Jean, making his film scoring debut. It is clear
that Jean worked very hard on the music to make it effective and put in
precisely the right place, and it admittedly does work.
By the time the ending arrived in "Life," without giving too much away,
Claude and Ray are ninety-years-old, and although everything concludes
on an upbeat note, it's a little difficult to pass by the reality that
these two characters are going to be dead soon. Sure, they've hung on to
each other's friendship, but that's not enough for me to walk out of the
theater singing a happy tune. Honestly, not only did the film turn out
to be a downer for me, but as I write this a mere eighty minutes after
seeing it, much of the film has already exited my long-term-memory.
After the disasterous "Dr. Dolittle," the well-meaning misfire, "Holy
Man," and the mediocre, forgettable "Life," perhaps Murphy should begin
to choose his feature film projects a little more wisely. After all, as
this movie can certainly attest to, life is short.
Copyright © 1999 Dustin Putman