Review by LarryG 4 stars out of 4
Being There is a sprawling, fun cd. It probably didn't have to be 2 discs
but going beyond 1 disc is a symbol of the band's ambition and often charmingly meandering
style. The first disc is clearly strongest. Every song is definitely a keeper and Wilco
mixes things up so it doesn't get too heavy or too light. It starts with Misunderstood,
which keeps building in intensity until the tension gets so high that the song dissolves
into dissonance. They follow with the considerably lighter Far, Far Away and then pick
things right up with the great rockers Monday and Outtasite(outta mind). They take a rest
with the endearingly dopey country song Forget The Flowers, then follow that with a
heartbreaking lost love song Red Eyed and Blue and to keep things from getting too serious
they launch into the delirious rocker I Got You where it seems the band is having such a
good time that they don't want to stop. The general sense is of a band having a good time
but still willing to try new things. The transcendent Hotel Arizona is hypnotically
intense but still a fun rocker. Only the knowingly stupid Kingpin is unable to find the
right balance. Part of the charm of Being There is that singer/writer Jeff Tweedy is
clearly a music fan. Many of the songs are about loving music, from The Lonely 1 about
unashamedly being a groupie to Someone Else's Song, about the difficulty of doing
differently and better than your idols. The playing is great on the rockers and the slow
ones. Being There shows a band able to make a great rock record and looking to still get better.
Here's what others reviewers have to say:
"...Tweedy and his band break free from the confines of the
arrow Tupelo legacy by exploring the nuances of noise and atmosphere....a
product of ambitious versatility, particularly in the string-band textures
conjured by...Max Johnston..." 4 Stars (out of 5) Rolling
Stone 11/14/96, pp.111-112
"...trades unity in for riskier mood swings....For all his
banjo-loving folksiness, he understands a simple secret: That rock'n'roll
as invented to fly in the face of country's qualms...to offer a few ho
little minutes of joy..." 7 (out of 10) Spin 11/96,
pp.122-123
|