|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Legends of the Fall
|
 out of 4
| *Also starring: | Aidan Quinn, Julia Ormond, Henry Thomas, Karina Lombard, Gordon Tootoosis, Tantoo Cardinal, Paul Desmond |
|
 Review by Dragan Antulov 2 stars out of 4
|
In Southeast Europe traditional folk songs with erotic content
often use the motive of old man and his three sons, usually
comparing the sexual prowess of those characters. The author of
this review has been reminded of this cultural tradition while
watching LEGENDS OF THE FALL, 1994 epic melodrama directed
by Edward Zwick. Reason for that could be found in the plot that
accidentally followed the above mentioned formula. In the
beginning of 20th Century retired U.S. Army colonel William
Ludlow, disgusted with the way his country had dealt with Plane
Indians, lives at a remote Montana ranch with three sons - oldest
and most practical Alfred (played by Aidan Quinn), middle and the
wildest Tristan (played by Brad Pitt) and the youngest and
idealistic Samuel (played by Henry Thomas). After being at
college, Samuel brings his beautiful fiancee Susannah (played by
Julia Ormond) to the ranch, and she soon falls for the wild and
more manly Tristan. However, these romantic complications are
nothing in comparison with the great historic events that would
affect Ludlows' lives. The Great War has started in Europe and
Samuel, not discouraged with the fact that USA is still neutral and
against his father's better judgment, decides to take part in it. He
goes over the border into Canada and volunteers in British army,
while two other brothers follow him, hoping that they could watch
over him. But the muddy trenches of France are just one of many
tragic ordeals that awaits them in the future.
For some, LEGENDS OF THE FALL with the plot that confronts
noble and savage nature with corrupted civilisation might seem
like another of Hollywood's attempts to exploit "politically correct"
trends of early 1990s, best embodied in DANCES WITH WOLVES.
For others, LEGENDS OF THE FALL is simply Hollywood's attempt
to recreate the good old epic melodrama - genre that almost
vanished from in modern times. In any case, Edward Zwick,
director best known for his work on television and 1989 Civil War
epic GLORY, was perhaps not so suitable to reconcile those two
ambitions. The film looks beautiful - cinematographer John Toll
captured Canadian exteriors very well, Julia Ormond is attractive
and quite convincing as femme fatale, while Brad Pitt would
certainly create droolfest among female segments of the
audience. The acting is also good, although Anthony Hopkins
seems to be tragically underused due to some melodramatic plot
points. However, good looks of the film still can't compensate the
inadequacies of the plot, responsible for LEGENDS OF THE FALL
drowning in melodramatic cliches, while Zwick has problems with
the pace, resulting in film being overlong and being burdened by
un-catharthic ending. However, the attractions here definitely
outweigh the flaws, and LEGENDS OF THE FALL can be
recommended to all the viewers hungry for movies that Hollywood
knew to make some thirty or forty years ago.
Copyright © 2002 Dragan Antulov
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|