| Reviewer Roundup |
| 1. |
 | Harvey Karten |
 | review follows |
 |    |
| 2. |
| Steve Rhodes |
| read the review |
|   |
|
Review by Harvey Karten
3 stars out of 4
Parents who were once sandal-wearing, grass-smoking alums
of Woodstock may wonder why their kids are so clean-cut,
conservative, even emotionally constipated--a reversal of the
usual roles played by the old folks with their youngsters. For
their part, the young ones may imagine that they were switched
at birth, that somehow these cannot be their parents! I think
we've all had fantasies at one time that when the cradles were
sorted out we somehow wound up with the wrong people.
Birth-switching is not only a device to motivate some key action
in the story but is central to director Claude Chabrol's theme:
that nothing within a family circle is certain. A person can be
good at times and perversely evil at others. One can be sweet
and charming and yet harbor murderous thoughts. A clean,
ordered, well-appointed household can sustain inhabitants who
are willing to do the worst against others without a trace of
emotion. Every moment of this film embraces Chabrol's theme
of subtle change, with the director's even employing the
metaphor of the piano: the various ways to interpret a
composer's creation as a symbol of uncertainty.
The story, adapted for the screen by the director and Caroline
Eliacheff from Charlotte Armstrong's story, "The Chocolate
Web," uses a brown throw crocheted by its central character,
Mika (Isabelle Huppert), as its primary symbol. The throw, in
the shape of a chocolate web, points to both the product made
by the company Mika inherited from her father and that
woman's perverse nature, which is "come into my web, said the
spider to the fly." Mika has remarried a concert pianist, Andre
Polonski (Jacques Dutronc) after the latter's second wife had
died, having fallen asleep at the wheel. She becomes the
stepmother of the aimless 18-year-old Guilaume Polonski
(Rodolphe Pauly) who happens to be the exact age of a
neighbor, Jeanne Pollet (Anna Mouglalis) whose mother,
Louise (Brigitte Carillon), is a doctor working in a forensic lab.
Upon suddenly hearing that there had been at least a temporary
mixup in the hospital when she was born, Jeanne begins to
wonder whether Andre might be her real daddy, particularly
considering her resemblance to Andre's second wife, Lisbeth,
and her ability with the piano. As the lively Jeanne plunges
headlong into the Polonskis' Lausanne, Switzerland mansion,
pumping Andre and later her own mother for clarification of her
birth, she charms Andre into giving her lessons.
Matthieu Chabrol's original score and the music of Liszt are
insinuated throughout the film, which is photographed By
Renato Berta creatively and without an American-style frenzy
mostly within the pianist's home. Carefully and subtly we in the
audience are asked to wonder about the hot chocolate made by
the heiress. Did she add her husband's regular sleeping
prescription, Rohypnol, to his second wife's drink to cause her
to die at the wheel? What sort of potion is she mixing for others
who get into her way, namely the 18-year-old woman who is
causing her husband to feel young again? By extension, what
might be in store for the aging board member Dufreigne (Michel
Robin), who criticizes her marketing strategy at the company's
meetings?
"Merci pour le chocolate" is a tone poem centered by Isabelle
Huppert's riveting performance, a story set to music which, like
Liszt's own tone poem is about shades and variations rather
than, say, like a bold symphonic work with crashing themes like
Beethoven's Fifth. Interestingly, the seventy-three-year old
director had studied pharmacy, intending to move into his
father's business, before he switched to film making which
explains in part his use of a prescription drug and the forensic
lab that employs two of his characters. Like Alfred Hitchcock,
Chabrol uses characters who are detached, in this case almost
narcoleptic, to further his vision of the turbulence that lies within
them just as he did in two other "detached" works, "Les Cousin"
and "Les Biches." "Merci pour le chocolat" is nicely nuanced,
witty and humorous at times, building its tension without any
concession to off-the-wall Hollywood-style melodrama.
Copyright © 2002 Harvey Karten
|