Overheard during a voir dire in the jury room: D.A. "Are you
capable of giving this case your unprejudiced verdict?"
Prospective juror: "No, sir. Until you're in another man's shoes,
you're in no position to judge him." The defense lawyer wanted
this guy, but no surprise: he was rejected. While other people
make impressions on us, favorable or not, we cannot really
(rhymes with Gigli) know how another feels unless we're in that
person's shoes. This sounds like an impossible feat, that is until
Barbara Harris and Jodie Foster changed places in Gary
Nelson's movie 1977 movie "Freaky Friday" to gain more insight
in a day than would be possible in years. Then, a 12-year-old
came along in Penny Marshall's movie "Big" to find out what it's
really like to be 30.
The theme is fascinating: no wonder Mark S. Waters is able to
capitalize on the notion in this updating of the 1977 film of the
same name, this time using Lindsay Lohan where Jodie Foster
tread 36 years ago and Jamie Lee Curtis as the hapless mother,
substituting for Barbara Harris of times past. Who would have
guessed that a PG story without winks and hidden messages for
the older folks in the audience would be a perfect vehicle for
putting across one of life's most important lessons--while
simultaneously being the most entertaining Hollywood comedy
so far this year?
Credit for this achievement must go to Heather Hach and
Leslie Dixon, whose screenplay is sharp and punchy, to Mark
Waters, directing against type (his "House of Yes" was a black
comedy dealing in part with the JFK assassination), and to the
wonderful chemistry between Jamie Lee Curtis as comic
virtuoso and the beautiful Lindsay Lohan as the teenager she
learns to get along with.
"Freaky Friday" begins with a premise that no one can argue
with: even people with similar genetic makeups have different
agendas. Casting aside the absent parents who don't give
much of a fig what their kids are doing, the typical American
mom is conservative, too often demanding that her child does
things that mother might like but which are anathema to the
youngster. The young 'uns for their part are repeatedly testing
to see what they can get away with, secretly hoping at times to
be paid attention to and scolded when they know they've gone
beyond the limits.
Dr. Tess Coleman (Jamie Lee Curtis) and her 15-year-old
daughter, Annabell, do not get along, in part because the teen
does not accept the man her mom is going to marry three years
after the death of her dad. Tess proves that psychoanalysts can
make pretty bad mothers, repeatedly blaming her teenaged
daughter for fights actually started by the girl's kid brother (Ryan
Malgarini). When an elderly proprietor of a Chinese restaurant
witnesses the friction, she employs voodoo-like, fortune-cookie
magic. Mother and daughter wake up the next morning with
exchanged bodies, but not minds, so that each could literally
see and feel the other person's point of view. They cannot
change back until each has demonstrated selflessness toward
the other.
The comedy, which moves at a brisk pace with only a few
minutes of obligatory sentimentality at the conclusion, puts Tess
and young Anna in situations that are stressful. They have no
idea how to comport themselves while trying to fool others into
thinking the newly-matured Anna is now her mom while the
now-youthful Tess is a rebellious teen. Nonetheless in some
ways each acts according to authentic feelings. Anna-in-Tess's-
body gets her hair cut short, her ears pierced, and replaces
sensible shoes with boots. Tess-in-Anna's-body puts her hair
modestly up and talks to her school friends as though she were
their adult adviser.
During the changes, mom understands the truth: that her
daughter's insistence she's being picked on by her English
teacher (Stephen Tobolowsky) is correct and that rock music
need not be just noise. (It helps that the songs belted out in the
soundtrack are intelligible and exciting.) Daughter realizes that
her mom's desire to marry again is perfectly natural.
While we get advice that pop psychologists give us in books
magazine columns, and talk shows, information of that nature
has a way of bypassing our subconscious. In other words, in
one ear and out the other. But put the other person's shoes on
and then some, namely, actually become the other person in
body but not in mind, and you'll see how experience is the best
if not the only real teacher.
While the movie is too wholesome to merit status as an instant
classic, this version is hipper than the 1977 pic, the actors have
a ball trying out new roles, and parents who take their kids may
not get to understand them better (after all, they're not
exchanging bodies) but they'll be thoroughly entertained.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten