Michael Moore's politics are as far left as you can get short of
being a socialist. On affirmative action, for example, the title of
his book "Stupid White Men" tells it all that this country is
unfortunately run by the same people he'd refuse to hire for any
job he personally undertakes. Moore, a New Yorker Upper West
Side of course is not the most tolerant guy you can imagine. In
"Bowling for Columbine" he shows his contempt for the Nike
company CEO, to take just one of many examples, a
corporation that pays pennies per hour for the Indonesians who
make the athletic shoes. He's shocked that this CEO has never
been to Indonesia, not even to visit a typical factory making the
product that made him a multi-millionaire. In "Roger and Me," he
seeks to track down General Motors chairman Roger Smith to
show him what his factory closing did to the town of Flint,
Michigan. If you don't think General Motors has any
responsibility to keep up the roster of employees it once had in
that hapless city, you'll simply have to agree to disagree with
Moore. But even if you're ferociously against the
documentarian's political beliefs, you're likely to see any film
with his signature for one reason: Moore is funny. No dour leftist
who lectures us about the evils of trans-national corporations,
he takes a light touch because he obviously
realizes that unless you're entertaining, you're not going to get
your message. A spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down.
You may wonder how he can tastefully inject humor into his
essay called "Fahrenheit 9/11," whose title carries us back to
Francois Truffaut's 1966 adaptation of Ray Bradbury's sci-fi
novel depicting future Earth civilization where all printed
material is banned, and also, of course, to the fateful day in
2001 when 3,000 people were killed in the worst punishment
ever inflicted on American civilians by a foreign entity.
In "Fahrenheit 9/11" Moore is fair and balanced just as Fox
News is fair and balanced, but Moore's leftist allegiances are a
welcome antidote to Fox's love for corporate power. (Ironically
enough, Disney honcho Michael Eisner's refusal to allow
Miramax to release this movie is as good a testament Moore
could get about the overwhelming power of corporate America
to get its way though much praise is due to Lions
Gate for picking up where the Weinstein brothers were
rebuffed.)
If there is a theme that runs through "Fahrenheit 9/11" it's that
Bush has got to go. The writer-director never actually says this:
he allows our President and his staff to make the case for
termination better. ince we're dealing largely with the war in Iraq,
where hundreds of Americans lost their lives, you'd think that
humor would be contraindicated but somehow Moore catches
the big kahunas, particularly Bush, in situations that allow us to
laugh at the president's unintentional humor. Consider how, on
the golf course, Bush delivers an off-the-cuff remark on how
terrorism must be destroyed, following his high-level, if obvious,
plea with "Now watch this drive."
A considerable part of the film deals with our relations with the
Saudis, more specifically the friendship between Saudi rulers
like that country's ambassador to the U.S. Prince Bandar who is
nicknamed "Bandar Bush" because of the cuddly relationship
the two enjoy. The Saudis have given Bush, Bush Sr. and
members of the Bush coterie one point five billion dollars.
Perhaps there's good reason to dos-a-dos with the Saudi
regime considering that the Saudi's own seven percent of
America some eight hundred billion dollars in investments.
Anger them and their withdrawal of funds could cause
considerable havoc with the stock market.
The most involving part of the two-hour doc deals not with
esoteric issues surrounding Saudi Arabia, whose "democracy"
is exhibited on screen albeit at a distance as we watch an
executioner behead a prisoner with two blows of the sword.
While there's much on Moore's mind to turn him off on Dubya
such as the documentarian's conviction that the Election of 2000
was stolen from Al Gore the current war most infuriates the
film-maker. The vast majority of soldiers now fighting and dying
are from poverty classes, with Flint Michigan coming in for some
nice sweeps of the camera across ramshackle housing in a
town that has an unofficial rate of fifty percent of its population
unemployed or underemployed. Young men and women without
hope, without jobs, find a place in the armed forces, little
realizing that they'd be sent to the fiery hell that is Iraq while, by
contrast, only one of America's five hundred thirty-five
congressmen and senators has a child over there. (In the film's
most humorous moments, Moore reads the Homeland Security
Act over an ice-cream truck's loud-speaker to our legislators
surrounding the Capitol building since, as he finds out from one
outspoken lawmaker, nobody reads most of the bills that are
voted into law.
Particularly emotional clips include one of an American woman
whose son died "for nothing" and more than one of Iraqi civilians
whose innocent loved ones were killed by what they call the
hated occupiers. (Bush at one point states, "Nobody wants to be
occupied. If I were occupied, I'd be angry too!")
Well-known character who take center stage in addition to the
President include Donald Rumsfeld, Condoleeza Rice, and Paul
Wolfowitz (who prepares for a TV interview by wetting his comb
in his mouth and finishes by spitting on his hand, then rubbing
his hand into his hair).
Leaving the film, we can't help getting the impression that John
Kerry who is not mentioned in this documentary is a shoo-in for
office. We can only wonder what the pro-Bush citizens will think
of the film if they even bother to see it: no other president in
memory, not even Nixon, was eviscerated in a movie with such
a deft combination of humor and fury.
Copyright © 2004 Harvey Karten