out of 4
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Review by Steve Rhodes
2 stars out of 4
BIG FISH is an overstuffed Christmas movie about a dying father who has spent
his life telling non-stop tall tales to his family and about his estranged,
grownup son who wants his dad to stop lying and finally tell the truth. This
PG-rated fairy tale for adults is directed by Tim Burton (SLEEPY HOLLOW) and
features Albert Finney as the father, Edward Bloom, and Billy Crudup as his
son, William. Ewan McGregor, as the young adult Edward, is actually the star
of the movie as well as of all of the older Edward's whoppers. The episodic
story has a cast of thousands that includes parts for Jessica Lange, Alison
Lohman, Helena Bonham Carter, Steve Buscemi and Danny DeVito, among others.
As the father retells his oft-told tales, he peppers us with little homilies.
"A giant of a man can't have an ordinary sized life," the younger Edward
remarks. His character is so much like a slightly smarter Forrest Gump that I
kept waiting for the Ping-Pong competition.
DeVito plays Amos, a circus ringmaster and the owner of a giant, Colossus
(George McArthur), not quite as big as Karl (Matthew McGrory), Edward's giant.
Amos likes to lecture Edward with thoughts such as, "You're a big fish in a
small pond; but this here is an ocean, and you're drowning." Edward works for
three years for Amos while getting one clue a month as to the identity of the
woman that Edward saw once briefly in a crowd and fell in love with.
MATCHSTICK MEN's female lead, Alison Lohman, plays the part of Edward's love
interest. Like the rest of the cast, Lohman was much better in every other
movie she has been in.
The movie works sporadically but then falls into another long lull. Burton
seems more interested in the fanciful set decoration that in fashioning a
compelling story. The characters' bad and wavering Southern accents are an apt
metaphor for the movie itself. The accents come and go but sometimes, as much
by accident as by design, they do ring true.
BIG FISH runs a long 2:00. The film is rated PG for "a fight scene, some
images of nudity and a suggestive reference" and would be acceptable for kids
around 9 and up, but most kids will find little to interest them in the story.
Copyright © 2003 Steve Rhodes
Buy movie posters!