|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Alex and Emma
|
  out of 4
 Review by Harvey Karten 3 stars out of 4
|
The more things change, the more they remain the same, as
the French proverb goes, and if you don't believe that, you
might after seeing Rob Reiner's "Alex and Emma." Whether
you're living in America now or in in 1924 or the Athens of 500
B.C., your emotions will be about the same. Your dress, way of
talking, cultural mores might differ, but deep down your life will
still be defined with bliss, disappointments, successes and
failures and your inner life may be remarkably similar all around.
This dualism same emotions but different cultural attitudes--
helps to make the work of a novelist one of the more intriguing
jobs you can have. For the most part, you'll write what you
know, getting kicks out of creating composite characters based
on the people you're familiar with, even getting revenge on
those bosses and boyfriends, gold-diggers and girlfriends that
make your life miserable. You might even put a happy ending
on what in real life makes you sad or a bitter one to meet the
tastes of a contemporary audience.
You might think that a guy like Brad Pitt would generate more
chemistry with the glamorous Kate Hudson than Luke Wilson,
but Reiner creates a sweet, gal-next-door image from the
talented star who was more sophisticated in "How to Lose a Guy
in 10 Days" and hipper in "Almost Famous." Emma Dinsmore
(Kate Hudson) and Alex Sheldon (Luke Wilson) do not exactly
meet cute in this one, but their convergence is an original. Alex,
who has written a successful first novel, has become blocked
and because of gambling debts owes the Cuban mafia
$100,000. He has only thirty days to come up with the dough,
which has been promised to him by his publisher (Rob Reiner)
upon receipt of the manuscript. Since two thugs have trashed
his laptop computer, he needs a stenographer. His ad brings in
Emma, who in the tradition of romantic comedies is turned off at
first by the slob she meets at the door of his apartment. Once
Alex gets under way on the book, we see how his current
predicament is reflected in the Boston setting of 1924. In the
triangular romance invented by Alex Adam (Luke Wilson) must
come up with $500,000 in order to get the sophisticated Polina
(Sophie Marceau) to break up with the wealthy John Shaw
(David Paymer) to whom she owes that sum. At the same time,
Alex is tempted by one of Polina's employees, who is at first a
Swedish made, Ylva, then a German Elsa, a Spanish Eldora
and an American au pair Anna (all played by Kate Hudson), the
last representing a woman who genuinely cares for him.
Rob Reiner, a terrific comedian in his own right ("All in the
Family") and director of a series of films as diverse as the
romantic "When Harry Met Sally," the satirical "This is Spinal
Tap" and the fabulist "The Princess Bride," moves flawlessly
from the Boston of the current day to that city in 1924, using the
past as a mirror of Alex and Emma's growing affection in
contemporary times. This is a sweet romance that is not marred
by the predictable trajectory (boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy
wins girl) because Luke Wilson and Kate Hudson are so
adorable together that you wish them the best.
The film was shot primarily in the Greater Los Angeles area,
using the beach scene at Cabrillo Beach, the ferry dock and
boardwalk in coastal San Pedro, and just a single day in Boston
itself. Though the movie is not a remake, it is loosely based (of
all things) on the story behind the creation of Fyodor
Dostoyevsky's "The Gambler," about a man (based on the
author himself) who had just thirty days to finish a book or he
would have had to turn over all rights to his past and future
works to his creditor. "Alex and Emma" was written by Jeremy
Leven, who is no Dostoyevsky nor would he wish that
temperament on himself, but the picture is saved from being
mere fluff by the alluring flashbacks, giving the movie audience
far more entertaining insight into the job of fiction writers than
that awful computer software that promises to make you the
next John Grisham.
Copyright © 2003 Harvey Karten
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|