out of 4
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
A Guy Thing
Review by Steve Rhodes
2½ stars out of 4
A GUY THING, by SNOW DAY's Chris Koch, is a pretty stupid comedy that has a
much better cast than it deserves. The formula film begins with Becky
(Julia Stiles, SAVE THE LAST DANCE) on her first day on the job as a Tiki
girl for bachelor parties. After enduring a series of bad jokes -- the
three rings of marriage are: the engagement ring, the wedding ring and the
suffering -- soon to be ex-bachelor Paul (Jason Lee, ALMOST FAMOUS) drinks
himself into oblivion. The next morning he awakens with -- you guessed it
-- Becky in his bed. With Karen (Selma Blair, LEGALLY BLONDE), his fianc‚e,
on the way over, he has just enough time to hide the panties that Becky left
The lost panty scene, like most scenes in A GUY THING, is one that you've
seen many times before. There are also ones of people climbing out of
bathrooms in order to hide in trees and ones of Cheetos up the nose.
Whether through accident or luck, the movie does discover a few fairly fresh
sequences that are quite funny. The best of these are one involving a
underwear bin at a discount store and another at a police line-up.
Most of the time, you'll find yourself wondering exactly how you're supposed
to take A GUY THING. It's so clumsily directed that you begin to wonder if
it is intended to be a parody of a romantic comedy. There are certainly no
surprises. You know from the beginning that Paul will eventually realize
that the rigid Karen is not for him. He belongs instead with the
free-spirited Becky, who can't keep a job for more than a week, if that
long. The whole movie would be grating if it weren't for the performances
of the three leads. They try so hard that they actually do almost save it.
A GUY THING runs 1:41. It is rated PG-13 for "language, crude humor, some
sexual content and drug references" and would be acceptable for kids around
11 and up.
Copyright © 2003 Steve Rhodes
Buy movie posters!