"Spartacus" is very loosely based on a true story. Douglas is trained to be a gladiator by Marcellus (Charles McGraw) at a facility owned by Batiatus (Peter Ustinov), where Douglas falls for servant Varinia (Jean Simmons). In due time, Douglas leads a revolt and takes the complex, then raids the countryside building an army of slaves, among them "singer of songs" Antoninus (Tony Curtis).

Back in Rome, the politicians and generals discuss how to deal with Spartacus. These include would-be dictator Crassus (Laurence Olivier) and generous schemer Gracchus (Charles Laughton).

"Spartacus" is a good movie. The cinematography is impressive, and the cast of extras rivals "The Ten Commandments" for sheer size. While far from Kubrick's best work, the film is well directed. Douglas, Olivier, Laughton and Ustinov are entertaining and well-cast. When grimacing Douglas dunks McGraw's head in a hot bowl of soup, you will be cheering for him.

But "Spartacus" is not as good as its reputation. First of all, the action sometimes drags, especially during the romantic scenes. While the Romans are given witty and sophisticated dialogue, the slaves aren't as fortunate. Stone-faced, sexually ambivalent Curtis has to deliver lines like "It could be argued so, master." Douglas and Simmons actually have the exchange:

Douglas: "Oh, Varinia, Don't make me weak". Simmons: "You're strong enough to be weak." (several melodramatic lines later) Douglas: "Oh, Varinia, Varinia, Varinia."

The Romans are portrayed as either brutally repressive or morally corrupt. The slaves, in contrast, are gentle and noble, with strong family units. The consistency of these opposing depictions reduces the credibility of the film. The plot also has some needless and unlikely plot twists towards the end, involving Simmons and Douglas.

Douglas produced "Spartacus", replacing Anthony Mann with Kubrick after they had an argument. Douglas and Kubrick had previously worked together on the superior "Paths of Glory". Kubrick disliked the script but was stuck with it. Much of the footage never saw the theatre, and wasn't restored until 1991. "Spartacus" won the Golden Globe award for Best Picture. Tellingly, the Academy didn't nominate "Spartacus" for Best Picture, but it did award Oscars for Cinematography (Russell Metty), Sets and Costumes, and Best Supporting Actor (Ustinov).