A hate letter to today's twisted health care system, "John Q" is a
sometimes-thoughtful, sometimes-preachy rumination on the timely subject
that gets its effectiveness from yet another powerhouse performance
by Denzel Washington (2001's "Training Day"). For all of the missteps
that this highly-charged drama makes, there are just as many moments
that director Nick Cassavetes (1997's "She's So Lovely") and screenwriter
James Kearns hit the mark on, making spacious room for audience discussion afterward.
When one of their cars is towed away following their inability to
make payment on it, blue-collar factory worker John Archibald (Denzel
Washington) and his wife, Denise (Kimberly Elise), get a nasty wake-up
call to the financial troubles they are in. Their otherwise amiable
existence is cut short when their only son, Mike (newcomer Daniel
E. Smith), suddenly collapses during his Little League baseball game.
John and Denise are informed by heartless hospital director Rebecca
Payne (Anne Heche) that Mike is in dire need of a heart transplant,
and with John getting his job hours cut back to 20 per week, he does
not have the medical insurance to cover the $75,000 minimum down payment
needed for Mike to be put on the organ recipient list.
With all of their other possible options exhausted and Mike's condition
quickly deteriorating, John resorts to taking criminal action--he
locks all of the entrances to the emergency room and takes everyone
inside hostage. His plea is simple: either his son is put on the organ
recipient list immediately, or he will begin taking lives inside the hospital.
The premise of "John Q" wavers on the line of manipulation throughout,
sometimes even overstepping its boundaries, but the strong points
the film makes are enough to give John's radical actions a full believability.
The internal and external struggle presented of parents who love their
son so much they are willing to do anything to save him is genuine
and abstrusely affecting. The confusion, pain, anger, and desperation
of John and Denise is the strongest aspect of a story that does, admittedly,
fall into the trap of stereotyping.
The wide range of supporting characters, particularly the hospital
staff and hostage negotiators, are too cut-and-paste to match the
realism of John's plight. Because "John Q" presents such a negative
light on the health care system, the doctors are portrayed as little
more than money-hungry bloodsuckers, while the hospital director seems
to have so little heart she could have easily spared her own to save
their son and not even let it phase her. Anne Heche (1998's "Psycho"),
as Rebecca Payne, and James Woods (2001's "Riding in Cars with Boys"),
as the impatient Dr. Turner, make the most of their slight characters,
but are too intrinsically nasty to gain our respect when they have
a change of heart in the second half. Meanwhile, Robert Duvall (2000's
"Gone in Sixty Seconds") and Ray Liotta (2001's "Blow"), as feuding
hostage negotiators, get stuck in a pointless subplot that has little-to-nothing
to do with the story at hand.
Elevating the material is Denzel Washington, once again making the
case that he is one of the finest actors working in film today. Washington's
performance is, at once, focused, passionate, and heartbreaking, the
latter no more so than in a vital choice he must make in the climax.
Furthermore, a late scene between he and his dying son is so truthful
and poignant that it is difficult to even watch. Kimberly Elise (1998's
"Beloved") is excellent as wife Denise, backing Washington up every step of the way.
With tensions escalating at a rapid pace, the denouement of "John
Q" comes as a bit of a letdown, not exactly because it is too pat
and neat, but because the soapiness of the last scene does not do
much of what came before justice. Still, the film makes a provocative
case: with all of the billions of dollars hospitals rake in each year,
it is patently ridiculous that they cannot be more flexible when it
comes to people's financial problems. "John Q" may be too problematic
to be marked a great movie, but one thing definitely is: Denzel Washington.
Copyright © 2002 Dustin Putman