|
All-Reviews.com Movie/Video Review
Hilary and Jackie
|
   out of 4
| *Also starring: | James Frain, David Morrisey, Charles Dance, Celia Imrie, Rupert Penry-Jones, Bill Paterson, Nyree Dawn Porter, Vernon Dobtcheff |
|
 Review by Susan Granger 3 stars out of 4
|
No, it's not that Hilary and it's not that Jackie - and not
about First Ladies with philandering husbands. Instead, Anand Tucker's
interesting, insightful film revolves around the Du Pre sisters, child
prodigies with remarkable musical abilities. Hilary's the quiet, older
sister, a flutist, and Jackie's, the willful, flamboyant cellist. They
grew up, inseparable, in rural England during the '50s. Their early
years revolve around musical competition, but soon Jacqueline Du Pre
becomes famous, spending her life on tour, while Hilary opts for
marriage and family, raising chickens in the country. Their
relationship, however, doesn't grow any healthier. Quixotic Jackie
delights in "surprising" Hilary by appearing on her doorstep, and - on
one bizarre occasion - asks to "share" her husband, played by brash
David Morissey. Jackie's own husband, Argentine musician Daniel
Barenboim, hardly figures into the equation. Tragedy strikes when - at
the peak of her career - Jackie develops multiple sclerosis from
which she dies at the age of 42 in 1987. The key strengths of the film
are the performances. As Jackie, Emily Watson ("Breaking the Waves") is
vivacious to the point of maniacal, providing a stark contrast with
Rachel Griffiths' stability as Hilary. The real Jackie was evidently a
histrionic performer: selfish, spiteful, and sexually voracious. The
key weakness is Frank Cotterell Boyce's unwieldy screenplay, based on
"A Genius in the Family," Hilary Du Pre's autobiography. It's weighed
down with narration and repetitive detail, like a soap opera which,
annoyingly, repeats the story line often enough so that, if you missed
an episode or two, you can catch up immediately. Not unexpectedly,
Jacqueline Du Pre's friends are condemning the film, particularly cellist
Julian Lloyd Webber, brother of Andrew, who asserts: "What they've done
to her memory is scandalous!" On the Granger Movie Gauge of 1 to 10,
"Hilary and Jackie" is a stylish, intense 7. This sibling rivalry is far
from harmonious.
Copyright © 1998 Susan Granger
|
|
|
|


Buy movie posters!
|