What happens when you take an R-rated black comedy about gun-toting,
bank-robbing cheerleaders and edit it down to a PG-13? You get a tepid
farce with only a few stray moments that reveal what was originally on
the writer's fevered little mind. "Sugar & Spice" co-star Mena Suvani,
the femme fatale cheerleader from ''American Beauty,'' told an
interviewer, "It was really frustrating, because the movie we all signed
on to do was very dark and very offensive, and while the finished movie
is still that to a degree, it's completely different." Remembering who
signs the paychecks, she quickly added, "but I totally understand there
were two sides of it."
The film was titled "Sugar & Spice & Semiautomatics" until two
incredibly twisted boys entered Columbine High School on April 20, 1999
and left a trail of terror and death. Suddenly, the concept of armed
teen-agers didn't seem quite as amusing and the powers that be at New
Line Cinema decided to make a few changes. Their qualms were
understandable. At the time, the studio was facing a $33 million lawsuit
(since dismissed) claiming that a student psycho in Kentucky shot eight
fellow students as a result, at least in part, of seeing "The Basketball
Diaries."
So how much was cut from "Sugar & Spice?" A great deal, apparently.
Actor James Marsden ("X-Men") told the same interviewer, ''I saw the
R-rated cut of the movie six months ago, and I just peed myself.'' After
viewing the current PG-13 version, I can report with great assurance
that, when the closing credits roll, there won't be a wet pair of shorts
in the house.
The executives at New Line realized they had a dog on their hands. Days
after receiving a pass to a sneak preview of the film, I was informed
that the studio was un-inviting critics to the promotional screening.
This was a first for me. Studios marketing lousy movies routinely try to
dodge reviewers by scheduling screenings so close to the release date of
a film that critics are unable to write about it before their deadlines
(Example: the slasher flick, "Valentine," opens this Friday and is being
screened Thursday night). Sometimes they will set up a promotional
screening aimed at the target audience for a movie and simply not inform
the press. When dealing with an utter disaster like "54" or "The
Avengers," they don't prescreen the production at all, hoping for a
lucrative opening weekend before disastrous word of mouth sets in. But
this is the only time I've ever been told, "Well, we're still going to
have a sneak preview, but you can't come."
At this point, you may be wondering why, in light of the Columbine
tragedy, the studio chose to continue with the neutered production. Who
knows? Why did Jay Leno get the "Tonight Show" instead of David
Letterman? Why was a man as talented as John Goodman stuck in a show as
dreadful as "Normal, Ohio?" Why did NBC cancel "NewsRadio" while
renewing "Suddenly Susan" for an additional season? Why is Carrot Top
still working? There are certain questions concerning the entertainment
industry that will remain mysteries forever.
Oddly enough, the PG-13 version of "Sugar & Spice" isn't entirely
horrible. It's just… there. The cheerleaders, out to raise money for a
pregnant squad member, still use guns to rob a bank, but the weapons are
now fakes made of spare gun parts. A few shocking lines from the
original script remain (one of the girls casually announces, "those
pictures of Christ, all sweaty and bare-chested on the cross, always
make me hot.") but in their new context they seem jarringly out of
place.
I smiled twice over the course of the flick's 90 minutes; once during an
inspirational recitation of the lyrics from Madonna's "Papa Don't
Preach," and once when James Marsden's chronically exuberant character
pauses in the snack aisle of a grocery store and tells his beloved, "If
we have a girl, we should dress her like Little Debbie!" There, I just
saved you the cost of a ticket.
If you'd like to see a real black comedy about wayward youth, rent "The
Opposite of Sex" (I suspect the caustic voice-over narrative in "Sugar &
Spice" was "inspired" by the film). If you want a wicked satire set in a
high school, try "Election." If you're craving a perky cheerleader
comedy, check out "Bring It On," which at least has better dance
routines. And if you're still interested in shelling out good money for
"Sugar & Spice," then reread this review, you big lug.
Copyright © 2001 Edward Johnson-Ott